Tuesday, 5 May 2009

My View of Real Estate

Property is an interesting one...Personally, i like it.
Leveraged investments make financial sense to me.
A friend once asked me to explain my strategy. I had a bit of trouble explaining it and so decided to write it down to explain it better.
My strategy involves the creation of a portfolio of properties with as little deposit as possible.
The best way to explain it is with 2 imaginary friends Bill and Ted. Bill is a risk taker and Ted is a long term stratergiser.
Both Bill and Ted have saved up £10k each and want to spend it on property.
Bill and Ted each buy a £100k property 10% deposit of £10k. Assume that the real estate market is growing at 3% per annum which would equal compound growth of £3k per annum.
This means that £3k earned from £10k investment equal 30% per annum on both properties for both parties.
Bill and Ted then save up a further £10k each at the end of year one.

Decisions, Decisions!
Bill wants to buy a second property. Ted decides to put the money into his existing property to pay it off faster.

Recap after 12 months
Bill owns 2 x £100k properties, each with £90k mortgages.
Ted owns 1 x £100k property with a £20k invested and hence only £80k mortgage.
Assume there is a 3% annual growth rate

Now Bill has 2 properties with £10k invested in each, with a capital gain of 3% per annum. This would work out to £6k total gain (on both the 100k prop) or 30% return (£6k divided by £20k).

Ted has used the £10k and paid off more of the first mortgage. He has made a £3k return on now a £20k investment. Works out at 15% return.

Bill has 2 investments both earning him a compounded return of 30% per annum.
Ted has 1 investment earning him now 15% per annum and as he invests more into the property, so that return diminishes. (a further £10k investment will see the return go to 10%(£3k into £30k)
The best way to show this is by plotting the return over 25 years.




If Bill had two properties his portfolio would be worth a total of £420k (2 x £210k - rounded up) for a £20k investment and a £180k in mortgages.
Ted on the other hand invested £20k into one property and it is worth £210k but he has a mortgage of only £80k
Assume Bill and Ted have both been on interest only mortgages and decide to sell their houses.
Bill has made £420 - £180k mortgages = £240k less £20k initial deposit = £220k

Ted has made £210k - £80k mortgage = £130k less £20k initial deposit = £110k
From this you can see in theoretical / simple terms what the difference is between the two investment strategies.
BUT you say, i would go repayment and have my house paid off after 25 years etc etc.

If you go repayment @ an extra £200 per month (above your interest repayment) or £2400 per annum then you calculate the return of £3k on £22400 mean your return on investment is now only 13%. The theory is that if you then save the £2400 by taking out an interest only mort, combined with personal savings you would build up another £10k for a deposit for another house and rinse and repeat.

In 25 years time, you will have quite a few houses that if a few were sold would more than cover the outstanding mortgages of the other half. With these houses paid off, one could retire with a portfolio of income generating properties.
The moral is that the more you pay off, the return diminishes. However everyone needs to live somewhere. Your home is your greatest single financial asset generally. By paying it off, it affords you a greater deposit on another house later.

Of course there are loads of variables that can affect your decision process. Interest rates, the fact that it is practically impossible to buy one house with 10% deposit let alone many, maintenace and repairs to properties over their lifetime. Those times when tenants default on the rent or you have no tenants in to cover the mortgage.

Being a land lord is a pain but i feel worth it in thelong run.

Thursday, 30 April 2009

I want my Share

It all started with a friend. A friend was actively tracking the markets and regularly commenting on its ups and downs. I was too busy with work and other things to pay him much heed. One day he came to me with an idea. Oil (Brent) was dangerously near the $40 per barrel mark.
What if...What if we bought shares, funds or plain barrels of oil when oil reaches $30!?
It was practically a given that the oil price would not stay there long...

So with an idea or two and a pound or three, we waited patiently for oil to hit $30...

We are still waiting...Well to be fair, we recognised that the boat had sailed on $30 and we probably would never see $40 again in our lifetime.

But it was the catalyst that got me interested in shares and trading. For many years my father had been banging on about shares and how we (my brother and I) should get involved. I was not really interested as real estate was my focus. I saw the benefits of leveraged capital at work in a residential market and was actively saving for a portfolio in a very bullish market.

BANG! Bulls turned to bears almost over night. Giants fell and the unthinkable happened.

Property was no longer the leading light in my investment vision. (Mainly as mortgages were hard to come by...wonder why that was?)

I had to look else where to invest my few pennies. I also wanted an element of liquidity in an uncertain market. One that may have me waving the "London Lite" in peoples faces...

Shares...seemed like a good idea at the time! So utilising the facilities of my retail bank, i set up a share trading account and linked it to my online bank account (Easier than i expected to be honest). Then I added some "spare change" to the trading account.
As the proverbial saying goes "all the gear, no idea"...I had everything set up and not a clue what to invest in. Like an 8 year old with an air rifle, i was itching to shoot something.

But my uncertainty and ignorance held me back. I was not too keen to lose my hard earned cash in an impulsive gamble. So I started to read the up on the markets. By that I mean BBC Business page and the odd Financial Times.

Then it all happened! The entire financial sector crashed (January '09). Within 4 hours of opening the all the banks were down at least 20 / 30 %.

This was it. This was the moment i was waiting for! I bought some shares in the Royal Bank of Scotland at 24p per share. I thought I was so clever. It was my first share purchase. I now owned a brick or two of part of the largest bank in the UK!

The following 24 hours saw my first ever investment drop to 12p per share. I lost HALF my investment in a day! HALF! 50%! It was like I had gone to the bank, withdrawn some money and then standing in the street torn up the notes and burnt them! I was depressed and disillusioned.
So I did what any naive speculator does when he has not a clue. He spreads his loss by buying even more shares. So I took a few more pennies and bought shares at 12p per share. This thereby reduced my exposure to only 18p per share (24 + 12 / 2 = 18)

It was an anxious next few days as I watched the share price slowly recoup. When it reached 18 per share i was very relieved. I was square! While a large part of me was saying "flog it and reassess this investment stuff" another side of me was excited with the prospect of making a profit.
Fundamentally, i told myself, the share price was very under valued based on the previous share price, the BRAND that is RBS and the assets it possesses (granted some of these were Toxic). There was intrinsic value in the share. It was 70% nationalised and no chance of the government letting it sink. However a majority nationalised bank will probably never be as profitable as a fully privatised one.

A wise man once told me..."you are only poor if you sell!" Like most things in life, events such as these are cyclical. Every 7 or so years we have a dip in the markets. At the moment this is quite a big dip. 2000 / 2001 we had the .com crash. '89 we had another...'82 yet another. But for those companies that survived these culls, saw them bounce back stronger than before (share price wise)

So i stuck with the shares and have just seen them reach the 50p per share mark today. I have almost trebled my initial investment in 4 months. Almost 200% return.
If you think of it this way...If you earn £100k per annum (i don't, but it is a nice round easy figure), and you make £5k on the stock market in a year, that is the equivalent of getting a 5% pay bonus!

It is a great feeling to walk past a branch of RBS and think to oneself...I own a piece of that company! You are now a stakeholder in that companies success or failure.